
T.J. Watt continues to solidify his legacy as one of the premier defensive players in the NFL, recently being ranked as the second-best edge rusher in the league, according to a poll conducted among NFL executives, coaches, scouts, and players. This marks the second consecutive year that Watt has held the No. 2 position on this prestigious list—trailing only Cleveland Browns star Myles Garrett.
A Model of Consistency and Dominance
Watt, now 30, has been a cornerstone of the Pittsburgh Steelers’ defense since being drafted in the first round (30th overall) of the 2017 NFL Draft. His accolades speak for themselves: Defensive Player of the Year in 2021, six Pro Bowl selections, five All-Pro honors, and a spot in the NFL’s 2010s All-Decade Team.
In 2023, Watt led the league in sacks with 19, marking the third time in his career he’s done so. He currently holds the Steelers’ franchise record for career sacks, surpassing legends like James Harrison and Joey Porter. Beyond stats, Watt’s disruptive impact is seen in how offensive coordinators game-plan around him. Whether dropping into coverage, setting the edge against the run, or relentlessly pressuring the quarterback, he is a true three-down defender.
The Shadow of Myles Garrett
Despite his accolades, Watt continues to play in the shadow of Myles Garrett when it comes to public perception and league rankings. Garrett, who was selected first overall in the same draft class, has seen a meteoric rise in reputation, especially following his 2023 Defensive Player of the Year award. His combination of size, speed, and power is often viewed as more prototypical for the position.
However, Watt’s supporters argue that he is equally, if not more, productive, with a higher football IQ and a stronger all-around game. His ability to create turnovers, bat passes, and command double-teams on nearly every snap sets him apart.
Respect Across the League
One defensive coordinator who voted in the ESPN poll said, “If you’re game-planning against T.J. Watt, your entire protection scheme changes. He wrecks plays without even touching the quarterback.” Another scout noted that Watt’s leadership and motor are unmatched, stating, “He’s the heartbeat of that Pittsburgh defense.”
Coaches and analysts alike praise Watt not just for his athleticism, but for his relentless effort, attention to detail, and leadership qualities. His preparation and discipline have helped him remain productive even when faced with nagging injuries or increased attention from opposing offensive lines.
Contract Talks Loom Large
This recognition comes at a pivotal time in Watt’s career. He is entering the final year of a massive four-year, \$112 million contract signed in 2021. Negotiations for a potential extension have reportedly stalled, with Watt seeking to become the highest-paid non-quarterback in NFL history—potentially surpassing Myles Garrett’s recent \$40 million-per-year deal.
While the Steelers are known for their defensive identity and have historically rewarded homegrown talent, the front office now faces a complex dilemma: balancing cap space, team needs, and the escalating market for elite edge rushers.
Final Thoughts
Despite contract distractions, Watt’s placement as the No. 2 edge rusher in the league reinforces his reputation as one of the most feared defenders in the game today. His relentless pursuit of excellence, unmatched production, and respect among his peers make him not just a top-tier player but a future Hall of Famer in waiting. Whether or not he ultimately surpasses Garrett in these rankings, there’s no denying Watt’s place among the NFL’s defensive elite.